We think about college football 24/7 so you don't have to.

The Countdown

A bottom-to-top assessment of the F.B.S. landscape heading into the 2012 season.

Need to Know

Heaps’ Transfer Might Lead to Leach

On paper, Washington State should be Jake Heaps’ preferred landing spot. The former starter at B.Y.U., Heaps declared his intention to transfer earlier this week, making official what most believed would come to pass over most of the second half of the regular season. Heaps, who started most of his true freshman season and the first five games of 2011, lost control of his starting job in the second half against Utah State, a game the Cougars would come back and win late under Riley Nelson. Even after playing reasonably well in Nelson’s stead as an injury replacement in November, the writing was on the wall: Heaps, if he wants to start, needed to play elsewhere.

The Washington product will probably stay close to home. Geographic proximity is one of Washington State’s many draws, though geography takes a back seat to appeal of the new pass-happy offense due to be installed by Mike Leach during spring drills.

Washington State may appeal to Heaps for another reason, and this theory is frustrating to those who believed him to be the future of the B.Y.U. offense: Heaps may not be the sort of all-conference quarterback he seemed destined to become after a strong true freshman season.

In short, Heaps may top out at average, not excellent. If he wants to play in the Pac-12, perhaps Washington State’s lack of talent — when compared to the rest of the conference — gives him the best chance at playing time.

I don’t buy that. I still think Heaps can be a top-level college quarterback, and I certainly don’t think he left Provo because of he saw his career dwindling away: Heaps could have taken a redshirt in 2012, had he chose, then returned as a redshirt sophomore in 2013 and reclaimed the starting job. Heaps’ rationale for leaving B.Y.U. has more to do with a unsalvageable relationship with the team’s offensive coaching staff.

Heaps will land on his feet; there are dozens of programs who would offer him a seat at the table, and yes, that includes a solid portion of the Pac-12. Washington State is one of those schools. Despite having what seems to be a fairly strong stable of quarterbacks — Jeff Tuel and Connor Halliday — Leach will want to add more and more to his collection, and would be foolish not to accept Heaps as a transfer.

Lane Kiffin would be interested: Tennessee was one of Heaps’ five finalists in 2009, when Kiffin was in Knoxville. With Matt Barkley gone after the 2012 season, if not sooner, and several untested options fighting to become his successor, Heaps would add depth and experience to a position sorely lacking in proven commodities.

What about Washington? Heaps might consider it, but the starting job would only be available in 2013 should Keith Price continue his progression and depart for the next level a season ahead of schedule. Oregon State seems set at quarterback with true freshman Sean Mannion, though the Beavers could use more depth — most of the Pac-12 could use some depth, actually.

There’s a chance that Heaps could look outside the Pacific Northwest and the Pac-12, which would open him up to most of the pro-style or pass-heavy spread teams in the Big Ten and Big 12. Heaps could have picked his school as a high school senior; even if a bit of the bloom is off the rose, those coaches who gaped in amazement at his high school tape will remember what made him a can’t-miss prospect in the first place.

But I keep coming back to Washington State, a program that seems to fill most of Heaps’ hypothetical wish list. If familial concerns are what prompted his transfer out of B.Y.U., it stands to reason that he’d want to remain close to home. If Heaps want to play in a pass-first system, serving under Mike Leach for the next three years would fit the bill.

And if he wants to play, Washington State will provide ample opportunities to take the starting job in 2013. Tuel, a rising senior, will have exhausted his eligibility. Halliday had a marvelous performance against Arizona State in November, but to anoint him the future starter is premature. Playing in Pullman seems to provide Heaps all that he needs to reclaim some of his lost luster.

You can also follow Paul Myerberg and Pre-Snap Read on Twitter.

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,
Home  Home


  1. Cole says:

    he should just transfer to boise

    problem solved imo

  2. Bryan says:

    I think you are underestimating Connor Halliday, he threw for over 490 yards against ASU. Then he played well against Utah, including a second half comeback in which he was playing with a lacerated liver.

    There were two big time QB’s in WA in Heaps senior season, the thing is people looked past Halliday who was putting up superior numbers because he played in the GSL and not in the Seattle area. I still would rather have Halliday over Heaps 7 days of the week. I wouldn’t mind Heaps as a backup though, in that case he is more than welcome in Pullman.

  3. PeteP says:

    Heaps is an arrogant pup who thought himself better than his talent and skills. He utterly lacks leadership skills.

    Heaps likely maxed out his talent last season, given that his family had been going all out on mentoring and coaching and training for him for a decade.

    He is afraid of getting hit.

    He refused even to attempt to slow down defensive players after his many INTs, let alone tackle.


    For those who remember, he was the second coming of John Walsh, another top QB out of high school from the early 90s, hyped out of existence but without the mental ability to perform up to expectations.

    Heaps would not have started at BYU even if he had reshirted 2012……

Leave a Comment